Hard-to-Fill Role? Why Advertising and Headhunting Work Better Together

When a role has been open for weeks and the applications aren’t right, the usual reaction is to re-post the advert or hand the whole thing to an agency. There’s a third option that often works better: run the advert and the search at the same time.

Active and passive candidates

Every role has two pools of potential candidates.

  • Active candidates are looking right now. They’re on the job boards, they set up alerts and they apply. A well-written, well-placed advert reaches them.
  • Passive candidates are in work and not checking job boards, but would move for the right opportunity. They don’t see adverts, so someone has to find them and approach them directly.

For many roles the active pool is plenty. For specialist roles – an electrical and controls engineer, a senior developer, an experienced project manager – the best people are often already employed and firmly in the passive pool.

Why advertising alone can stall

On a hard-to-fill role, an advert can bring in plenty of applications without bringing in the right ones. Re-posting the same advert usually reaches the same people again. Paying a percentage fee for an agency to start from scratch, meanwhile, means losing the applicants the advert has already found.

Why headhunting alone isn’t always the answer

Headhunting reaches the people adverts can’t, but it’s a focused search rather than a broad net. Some excellent candidates are active and would happily have applied to an advert. Running only a search can mean missing them – or paying a recruitment fee for someone an advert would have found.

Using both: how Talent Hub works

Talent Hub is our solution for exactly this. It blends fixed-fee advertising with professional headhunting so both pools are covered at once.

  1. Advertise. Your branded advert goes live across our job board network from £390 + VAT, and the applications are screened against your criteria.
  2. We introduce. At the same time, a senior consultant headhunts active and passive candidates, screens them against your brief and introduces them alongside your advert applicants.
  3. You choose. CVs from both routes land in your ATS, and you decide who to interview.

The fee structure follows where your hire comes from. Hire someone who applied to the advert and there’s nothing more to pay. Hire one of the candidates we introduced and the fee is 10% of salary, with the cost of the advert deducted from it. If you’d rather your consultant handled the advert applicants as well, that’s available as an upgrade.

See Talent Hub on our services page

Other ways to widen the net

  • Search & Select – if you want more candidates than your advert brings in but plan to handle them yourself, we’ll search the UK’s major CV databases and add up to 30 matched candidates to your ATS for a flat price per role. More about Search & Select
  • Headhunting – for senior IT & Engineering roles where an advert isn’t the right fit, our consultants run the full search on a 12% no win, no fee basis. How our headhunting works

Which roles suit this approach?

  • Roles that have been advertised before without the right result
  • Specialist technical and engineering roles
  • Senior hires where the best candidates are likely to be employed
  • Roles where timing matters and you can’t wait for a second advert

If you’ve got a role that isn’t filling, send us the brief or call 01603 415 100 and we’ll tell you honestly whether an advert, a search or both will get you there.

Hiring in a specific sector? See how we recruit for engineering, manufacturing, logistics and HGV drivers, construction, retail and customer service, skilled trades, care and energy.

Hard-to-fill role?

Advertise and headhunt at the same time

Send us the brief and a consultant will come back to you within one business day, or price an advert and headhunt together in our calculator.

See your price →Send us a brief

Or call us on 01603 415 100.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top